Browse Our Current Specials

Garage Door Replacement vs. Repair

Knowing whether to repair or replace your garage door helps you address problems you’re experiencing. We’ve listed the pros and cons of garage door repair and replacement and the best resolution for your needs.

Should I Repair or Replace My Garage Door?

Depending on the extent of the damage, the benefits of repairing or replacing it vary. We’ll explore some pros and cons of both options.

Pros and Cons of Repairing a Garage Door

Repairing your garage door may be a cost-effective alternative to replacing it, but it has some potential drawbacks. 

Pros of Repairing Your Garage Door

Besides being cost-effective, additional pros include:

  • Quick and convenient: Fixing a door is quicker and more convenient than replacing it, which is a lengthier process.
  • Sustainable option: Repairing your garage door is more eco-friendly because it uses fewer materials.

Cons of Repairing Your Garage Door

Here are some possible cons of garage door repairs:

  • Short-term solution: Constant repairs may become costly in the long term, especially if you experience persistent garage door issues. 
  • Warranty: Not all repairs carry a warranty unless the same covered part breaks.

Pros and Cons of Replacing a Garage Door

While repairing your garage door is effective in most cases, replacing it may be the better option. Explore the pros and cons of replacement.

Pros of Replacing Your Garage Door

The pros include:

  • Long-term solution: A new garage door will last years compared to one that’s repaired.
  • Warranty: New doors have comprehensive warranties to protect them against damage and cover repairs.

Cons of Replacing Your Garage Door

Keep these points in mind with a replacement:

  • Costly alternative: It costs more to replace a garage door.
  • Lengthier process: Choosing a door and installing it takes longer.

When to Replace a Garage Door

The older a garage door is, the more wear it has undergone. If it’s older than 15 years, it may need replacement if there are obvious, irreparable signs of damage. If the door is not old but has experienced significant damage caused by a storm or vehicle, it should be replaced. 

Fixing your garage door repeatedly becomes expensive over time. It may be better to invest in a new garage door instead.

Is It Better to Repair or Replace Your Garage Door Opener?

We suggest repairing your door in the following instances:

  • Under warranty: Check that it is still under warranty and confirm the terms of coverage.
  • Costly to repair: If a repair is expensive, replacement could be a better option.
  • New but malfunctioning: A faulty opener should be inspected and repaired.

Replacing an opener may be required in these cases:

  • Overuse: Heavy use can cause damage, creating a need for replacement.
  • Age: An opener older than 10 years should ideally be replaced.
  • Frequent repairs: Repeated repairs are costly and accumulate over time, so replacement is a better alternative.

Trust AE Door & Window for Garage Door Replacement and Repair

At AE Door & Window, we’ve been keeping garage doors in greater Cincinnati and beyond in great condition, and we look forward to serving you, too. 

We can repair your garage door if it doesn’t run as it should. We also provide preventive maintenance services to help your door last longer, and we can replace it if necessary.

Schedule a service with us today!

View All Testimonials